Posts Tagged https://regmedia.co.uk/2019/12/16/cobalt_lawsuit.pdf
News broke a few weeks back on the class action suit introduced in the USDC for the District of Columbia, against Apple, Dell, Microsoft and Tesla. Swiss-based Glencore (of Mark Rich fame) and Belgium’s Umicore are mentioned in the suit but not added to the defendants. Historical references are inevitably made to the plundering of Congo first by King Leopold personally and in a later stage by the Kingdom of Belgium.
The suit is a strategic one, attempting to highlight the human rights (including child labour) issues involved in the mining of cobalt, used as a raw material in particular for modern batteries, and to propel the corporate social responsibility (CSR) debate on due diligence and supply-chain liability. It is also however a suit seeking damages for the victims of child labour in very dangerous circumstances.
Of note for the blog is the jurisdictional angle: discussed at 18 ff and featuring arguments against the use of forum non conveniens. Claimants put forward they have no practical ability to litigate in DRC: damages under DRC law (therefore assumed to be the lex causae which a Congolese judge would apply were the case litigated in DRC) sought from end-users of cobalt; DRC courts are corrupt; anyone standing in the way of the mining industry is threatened; the 2000 Victims of Trafficking and Violence Protection Act TVPRA as amended in 2013 allows for extraterritorial jurisdiction; finally and of relevance to a classic locus delicti commissi argument: ‘the policymaking that facilitated the harms Plaintiffs suffered was the product of decisions made in the United States by Defendants’.
Personal jurisdiction is suggested to exist for (at 22) are all U.S. resident companies and they do substantial and continuous business within the District of Columbia – minimum contacts are established, and defendants should reasonably anticipate being hailed into court there.
No doubt there will be intense discussion on the jurisdictional basis, prior to debate on the merits of liability of end-users.
Cobalt, Corporate social responsibility, CSR, Dell, due diligence, Extraterritoriality, FNC, forum non, Forum non conveniens, Google, https://regmedia.co.uk/2019/12/16/cobalt_lawsuit.pdf, Jurisdiction, Locus delicti commissi, Microsoft, strategic litigation, supply chain, Tesla, TVPRA
- Attempt in the Austrian courts to repeal air traffic tax breaks puts polluter pays and CJEU Deutsche Bahn judgment in the spotlights. 08/04/2020
- Sánchez-Bordona AG in Volkswagen. The locus damni engine is clearly revving. Locus delicti commissi in my view left underdiscussed. 07/04/2020
- Supreme v Shape: Advocate General ØE on Brussels Ia’s scope of application (‘civil and commercial’ in light of claimed immunity. Opinion at odds with CJEU in Eurocontrol. 06/04/2020
- Wallis v Air Tanzania. A good reminder of the (soon to be resurrected) UK reservation viz the Rome Convention. 03/04/2020
- Aspen Underwriting: The Supreme Court overrules on the issue of economically weaker parties in the insurance section. 02/04/2020
Also of noteMy Tweets